How to Grow With OTAs Without Becoming Dependent
Most operators list everything, everywhere, permanently. That is a habit rather than a strategy.
Marketplaces put you in front of travellers who will never search your name because they have never heard of it. That is worth paying for, and the fee only arrives when it works — which makes commission an unusually low-risk form of marketing.
The trouble is not the channel. It is that most operators set it up once and never revisit it, so a decision that made sense in year one is still running in year five at considerably greater cost. This is how to use platforms deliberately — and how to tell when to lean in or step back.
What the commission actually buys
Three things, and they are worth separating because they age differently.
- Discovery. Placement in front of travellers who did not know you existed. This is the part you genuinely cannot replicate cheaply, and it matters most when you are new.
- Borrowed trust. A stranger will book through a platform they recognise long before they will send money to an unfamiliar business abroad. That gap narrows as your own reviews accumulate.
- Distribution mechanics — payment handling, customer service, refund processes. Real value, and largely invisible until you do it yourself.
There is a fourth claim often made, that being listed lifts your direct bookings as well. The research behind it is real but comes from hotels rather than tours, and the direct-versus-OTA guide works through what is actually established. Treat it as a reason not to abandon platforms rather than a number to plan around.
A listing strategy, not a listing habit
The default approach is to list everything on everything, on the reasoning that more shelf space cannot hurt. It can, in two ways.
Every listing needs maintaining — descriptions, prices, availability, photographs and reviews to respond to. Six platforms half-maintained perform worse than two done properly, because platforms rank on completeness and responsiveness as well as demand. And every listing is a place where your product can drift out of date without you noticing.
A more deliberate approach asks three questions per platform:
- Do my travellers use it? Source markets differ enormously in which platforms they book through, and yours are visible in your own booking data.
- Does my product suit it? Platforms skew — some toward day activities, some toward multi-day, some toward specific regions.
- Can I maintain it properly? If the answer is no, adding it makes your whole portfolio slightly worse.
For most operators the answer is two or three platforms, maintained well, plus a direct channel that actually works. Choosing between the largest two covers that decision specifically.
Vary exposure by product and season
Here is the idea almost nobody applies, and it is where the money is. Operators treat marketplace presence as binary — you are on a platform or you are not. In practice it is a dial, and it can be set differently for each product and each month.
The logic is straightforward once stated. You pay commission to generate demand. Where demand already exists, you are paying for something you would have had anyway.
Your signature tour in August, which sells out regardless, is the worst place to be paying 25% for demand. Your secondary product in November, which struggles to reach its minimum, is the best. Same business, same platforms, opposite decisions.
In practice that means:
- Full exposure on products that need demand — new tours, secondary products, anything with spare capacity.
- Reduced allotment in peak weeks on products your own channel fills. You are not delisting, you are offering fewer seats where they cost you most.
- Everything available in shoulder and off-season, where the commission buys demand that genuinely was not there.
- Watch the ranking cost. Platforms favour products with consistent availability, so a listing you empty every summer may rank worse in spring. Reduce rather than close, and reduce gradually.
This requires knowing which departures fill directly, which is an argument for shared availability across channels rather than fixed allocations — you can adjust the dial when the data changes rather than a season later.
Managing what you pay
Commission is more negotiable than most operators believe, and the reason they never find out is that they never ask.
Platforms want reliable suppliers with good ratings and low cancellation rates, because those keep travellers on the platform. If that describes you, you have a position — so contact your account manager with your numbers ready: booking volume, review score, cancellation rate, and how long you have been listed. What operators actually pay sets out the rates worth benchmarking against.
The other lever is optional programmes. Platforms sell promoted placement and accelerated visibility that raise your effective commission, and they are frequently accepted without anyone calculating the return. Treat them as advertising with a specific cost, judged on net revenue produced — not as a setting to leave on.
And check your booking software is not adding a percentage of its own on top of marketplace bookings, which is a cost operators frequently discover late.
Making the guest yours
The single decision that determines whether commission was expensive or cheap is whether you keep the customer.
Paying 25% once to acquire somebody who books with you three times is good marketing. Paying 25% every time is a distribution cost. The mechanism is not complicated — deliver a tour worth remembering, collect contact details on the day with consent, and follow up while they are still in the destination. Repeat business and referrals covers the practicalities.
The boundary matters and is worth repeating: you cannot divert a traveller mid-booking, and most platform terms prohibit soliciting a direct booking during the transaction. After they have travelled with you, the relationship is yours.
When to lean in, when to pull back
The right level of platform exposure changes as the business does, and reviewing it once a year is enough.
Lean in when you are new and nobody knows you exist, when you launch a product with no reviews of its own, when you enter a new source market, when you have unsold capacity you cannot fill directly, and in your quiet months.
Pull back — selectively — when specific products sell out directly, when your own name generates real search volume, when your direct booking flow genuinely converts, and when the commission on a given product exceeds what the same money would buy in advertising.
What almost never works is a wholesale exit. Operators who delist entirely tend to discover how much discovery they were receiving, and re-entering means rebuilding rankings and review counts from a standing start. Adjust the dial; do not switch it off.
Tracking the real return
Judging platforms on booking volume is how operators end up over-committed to the one that produces the most transactions at the worst rate. Three better measures:
- Net revenue per platform, after commission and after any software fee. This alone reorders most operators' view of which channel matters.
- Cost per acquired customer, not per booking. If a platform guest later books directly or refers someone, the original commission bought more than one tour — which is the whole argument for treating it as marketing.
- Repeat rate by original source. Rarely tracked and genuinely revealing: some platforms deliver travellers who come back, others deliver one-time transactions, and the difference should change how much you invest in each.
Review these once a season, at the same time you reconcile payouts, since that is when you are handling real net figures anyway. Reconciliation is where those numbers live.
How Travelity helps
Varying exposure by product and season only works if availability is genuinely shared rather than carved into fixed allocations. Travelity's channel manager keeps one pool of real-time availability across every connected marketplace and your own booking widget, so you can adjust the dial without risking a double-booking.
And because every reservation lands in one place with its source attached, net revenue by platform and repeat rate by origin are things you can read rather than reconstruct.
Frequently asked questions
Should I list all my tours on every marketplace?
No. Each listing carries real maintenance — content, pricing, availability and reviews to keep current — and products differ in how much they need the exposure. A signature tour with strong direct demand does not need to pay commission in peak season, while a secondary product that never sells directly should be everywhere it can be.
How do I reduce OTA commission costs?
Rates are more negotiable than most operators assume once you have volume and a good record, so ask, with your numbers ready. Beyond that, the practical levers are declining optional promotional programmes that raise your effective rate, and shifting exposure away from products and seasons where you do not need the demand.
When should a tour operator reduce marketplace exposure?
When a product is reliably selling out through your own channels, which usually means specific products in peak weeks rather than the whole business all year. Pulling back everywhere at once removes discovery you still need, whereas reducing availability on the departures you can fill yourself costs you nothing.
How do I calculate the real return on a marketplace?
Compare net revenue after commission against what the same effort produces elsewhere, then judge each platform on cost per acquired customer rather than per booking. A guest who later books directly, refers someone or writes a review that sells other tours makes the original commission look very different from a one-off transaction fee.
Is it risky to rely on OTAs for bookings?
The risk is concentration rather than the channel itself. Rates change, algorithms change and listings can be suspended, so an operator whose season depends on one platform has handed control of their business to a company that does not know they exist. Spread across a few platforms and a real direct channel, marketplaces are simply good marketing.
Bottom line
Choose two or three platforms and maintain them properly rather than listing everywhere badly. Then stop treating presence as binary — vary exposure by product and by season, so you are paying commission where it generates demand and not where the demand already existed.
Ask for a better rate once you have earned one. Keep the guests you acquire. And judge each platform on net revenue and repeat rate rather than booking count — because at that point marketplaces stop being a cost you resent and become a channel you manage.
Related guides
See Travelity in action. Book a Personalized Demo.
30 minutes that can completely change the way you run your travel business. See how Travelity can help you work smarter, sell more, and operate with less stress.